I was kinda surprised to see Saint's Row 3 as number 1,but I kinda see what he means,from what I saw my bro play of it,I honestly liked Saints Row 2 better.
for my personal list of games that weren't god-awful,but disappointed me...
1.Mortal Kombat ...online laggy and no co op tag team which is the reason I bought it $150 down the drain for two copies..
2.Dead Island,I agree with what angry joe said
3.Gears of War 3,the story was cool,but....the online was bleh to me,instead of a shotgun fest,it's a sawn off shotgun fest....horde was cool however
well that's all I can think of,I didn't get many games this year at all....some were great like Dark Souls and Skyrim and BF3(besides idiot randies online).I thought of getting dragon age 2 when it came out but good grief I heard it was bleh...the bleh graphics stuck out to me...I know graphics aren't everything,but for me to get "into" the game,I like for it to look good
edit: feel free to make your own lists too